Only Part of the Story: A Professional Assessment

I love TED Talks, and of course, I was interested in a talk by Amy Cuddle titled “Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are?  At the age of 19 Ms. Cuddle was in an extremely serious car accident that resulted in a traumatic brain injury. Afterward she was told that her IQ was lowered by 2 standard deviations.  She was informed that she would never finish college. Having always been identified as gifted she talks about how powerless she felt. Working extraordinarily hard, she overcame her deficits, and now she is faculty at Harvard Business School. She says, she always felt like an impostor, but why was the assessment given to her so incorrect.

As professionals we use observations, formal and informal evaluations which offer normative data used to gauge a person’s ability. This normative data gives information that is use to make predictions of future outcomes such as, “you will never finish college.” Normative data is based on how other people with a similar profile have responded after such as event.  It’s statistics, but people aren’t just statistics. The assessment continues to be the best way to understand the most likely outcome.

As a speech language pathologist providing an assessment of a person’s speech and language abilities is part of my job. An assessment, is only a glimpse of a person’s potential at one given point in time. The purpose of an assessment is to identify the problem(s), so that additional tools and resources can be targeted directly to areas of weakness.  Knowing the potential outcome of a particular profile is how large systems, such as schools and hospitals, decide to direct resources.  As an individual how do you know when to ignore the diagnose and continue to work hard or should you always ignore the diagnosis

After such a diagnosis, what makes one person never go to college while another finishes and becomes a University professor?  There are many factors that contribute to someone’s ability to achieve academically. Factors like motivation, attitude, resources, mental strength, intellectual capacity, and mental flexibility identify a few.  Other indicators of future potential after cognitive changes occur are the type of student a person was before the incident offers valuable information. Ability to work hard, determination, type of student are all additional factors that help improve the reliablilty of a diagnosis.  She knew how to learn and the discipline to pursue learning regardless of the difficulty. From my experience people with traumatic brain injuries often have headaches, confusion, dizziness etc. at least for several months. Studying would have been extremely difficult, but Amy Cuddle, who is now a professor at Harvard Business School, was not afraid of hard work.  Finally, assessments do not tell the entire story as Amy Cuddle’s recovery shows. We can never know what a person is capable of or if they will have the mental fotitude to overcome their challenges.

Similar posts
  • Music Instruction Develops Executive Function SkillsMy daughter often doesn’t want to practice her instrument, so much of my time and effort has been spent figuring out how to get her to practice her instrument, but I do because music instruction develops executive function skills and will improve other skills like math. Yesterday I  attended a yearly Martin Luther King event [...]
  • STOP the conversation! No one is listeningWhere are the conversations? In politics, conversations where people have differing views are impossible. People scream at each other. No one is listening to the other side. Democrats are outraged at Republicans.  Republicans push agendas in spite of the public outcries. No one is listening! How do we have conversations that move us toward healing and [...]
  • Transitioning to College with Learning DisabilitiesPost high school education can be challenging for students transitioning from high school with special education services on little or no transition planning.   Concerns about self-care, class preparation, and social interactions are ever-present for all freshman. However, especially for students with who have been fully supported with special education services through high school, the changes [...]
  • Homework Battles: What is the problem?Homework battles, whether once a week or every day, fighting your child to complete their homework is a dreaded chore. [...]
  • Mindblindness vs Context blindnessReplacing the generic term of “mindblindness,” often used to refer to people on the autism spectrum, with a more specific term such as “context blindness” has been proposed by Peter Vermeulen, PhD.   Simon Baron-Cohen created the term “mindblindness,” to refer to the deficit  people on the autism spectrum have in reading others mental states. This term [...]


  1. Minga Claggett-Borne Minga Claggett-Borne
    April 11, 2013    

    Nice Blog!!!

    In the title you probably meant to say Fake it TILL you make it.

    Minga Claggett-Borne writing counseling

    Why is there so little justice, with so many people praying for peace?

    • April 16, 2013    

      Thanks for the edit! Writing is best when it is a collaborative project.

    • April 25, 2013    

      No actually I did mean fake it in order “to” make it, so “to” is correct. However thanks for making me think about my wording.

  2. April 21, 2013    

    Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you
    relied on the video to make your point. You clearly know what youre
    talking about, why waste your intelligence on just posting
    videos to your weblog when you could be giving us
    something informative to read?

Leave a Reply


Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email.